Robbie is new to the forum. He was just very blessed by the PU. I see a fair host of things differently than Pastor JD. But i am often blessed by his heart toward the Lord. His passion to love on the saints. And his desire to bring His word to the flock. Even though I would have areas of differences with Pastor JD, those are the things I find very important as to how God uses him in my life. The passage you bring up Rodney is one area i would differ with him in.
However, even so, i do I like Andy Woods take on falling away as rapture:
Rapture or Apostasy in 2 Thess. 2:3? - YouTube
Am i sold on Andy’s view? Not exactly. But i do consider its weight. Overall i would see 2 Thes 2 half the way you do. And half the way you do not see it. Here is how i get there:
. . . . .
If you look at KJV, this helps i think get the sense of 2Thes2:1-2:
2 Now we beseech you, brethren, by the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ, and by our gathering together unto him,
2 That ye be not soon shaken in mind, or be troubled, neither by spirit, nor by word, nor by letter as from us, as that the day of Christ is at hand.
It makes “concerning” a beseeching. In the Greek interlinear, its “emplore you” not “concerning.”
2 Thessalonians 2:1 Interlinear: And we ask you, brethren, in regard to the presence of our Lord Jesus Christ, and of our gathering together unto him, (biblehub.com)
Its like saying: By the fact that we are going to be drawn to Him, there is no reason to be all tripping out you guys.
The next issue is IS IT “Day of Christ” OR “Day of the Lord” in verse 2? Most commentaries have it from the older manuscripts that it is Day of the Lord. Which mean the concern is the day of the Lord not the rapture. Or missing it. There is a case for the KJV using “Day of Christ” meaning something good (as it is used as such in other places…and could be the rapture referred). But i think what seals the deal is the following:
Notice in the Greek “has come” = is present OR currently occuring. How could they be tripping if the rapture is currently occuring? They would be excited. Not troubled. But if the day of the Lord, yeah…that would be a concern. And the Greek i believe solves the mystery. It is certain it is current ongoing (or presently right now happening underneath your feet).
"that you not be quickly shaken from your [b]composure or be disturbed either by a spirit, or a [c]message, or a letter as if from us, to the effect that the day of the Lord has come.
2 Thessalonians 2 Interlinear Bible (biblehub.com)
The Clearest way to understand this is: Don’t be troubled as though the Day of the Lord is happening right now."
. . . . .
Other than that, i do see the exegetical drive of 2 Thes 2 to be mid tribulation. This is where we might agree. As we look at what focus is on the man of perdiction it goes into these features (or at least this is where i would see everything exegetically cluster…so if we walk it back to the beginning of the text…that man of lawlessness’s import is in relation to the exegetical followng:
- makes himself out to be God
- demands worship
- Gets killled by Christ (that guy)
- Strong Delusion (massive deceptive supernatural false wonders and false miracles enforced by God because they saw AC and had been warned by the angel in midheaven not to take the mark…so God blinds them with miraculous fantasy).
. . . . .
Even though we see it differently there is a tendency today for us to have passion in defending His word. And this is understandable and commendable. But there are quite a few variables to consider at times. Even though i would differ for what i would understand as a proven difference with Pastor JD’s approach, i like what Andy Woods does with it so much…that perhaps there is dual meaning (or that in some ways it might actually mean both/and). Like can it be rapture in one sense and apostacy in another? Can God use the serpent on a pole to represent Christ? Can God be put to penal death for blasphemy? So because of Woods, i am more appreciative to consider Pastor JD’s sense about the passage. Not because i would see it as exegetically matching, but that God can do things with words that transcend even our poetic senses of them. And that kind of turns me on in the spirituall.
Galatians 3:16, blesings.